Joy was as standout member of the Butler women’s soccer teams from 1995-98, and she currently stands second on Butler’s all-time list for scoring (109 points) and goals (44). She earned All-MCC (now Horizon League) honors in each of her four years with the Bulldogs, including first-team recognition three times.
She was named MCC Newcomer of the Year in 1995, and she earned all-tournament honors in 1996, 1997 and 1998. She was named to the All-Great Lakes Region Team by both the National Soccer Coaches of America Association and by Soccer Buzz. Joy also stands third on the Bulldogs’ all-time chart for assists (21).