Sarah was a dominant performer on Butler’s successful women’s basketball teams from 1995 to 1998. She helped lead the Bulldogs to their first NCAA Tournament appearance in 1996, and she helped Butler to a WNIT berth in 1998. She earned first team all-conference recognition twice, was named to the league all-defensive team three times and was selected at the Midwestern Collegiate Conference (now Horizon League) Player of the Year in 1997-98.
The two-time Butler Most Valuable Player led the Bulldogs in scoring for two straight years and in rebounding for three consecutive seasons. She finished her career with 1,320 points, which currently ranks ninth on the Butler’s all-time scoring list, and she was named to the 10-player Butler University Women’s Basketball Team of the Sesquicentennial in 2005-06.